Tuesday, October 14, 2014

Effects of different levels of ozone on ammonia, nitrite, nitrate and dissolved organic carbon in sterilization of seawater

1Puji Rahmadi, 2Young Ryun Kim
1Ph.D. candidate at Ecological Engineering Dept., Pukyong University
2Ph.D. candidate at environmental Engineering Dept., Pukyong University
Pukyong National University, 599-1 Daeyeon 3-Dong, Namgu, Busan, South Korea, 608-737.
Tel. +8251 629 6541; Fax: +8251 629 7907; email:pujirahmadi@pknu.ac.kr

Ozone is applied to the recirculation aquaculture system (RAS) to reduce bacteria and parasites. Besides the sterilization effects, it is known that ozone has oxidizing effects on some water quality parameters. Therefore, oxidizing effects of ozone on ammonia (NH4-N), nitrite (NO2-N), nitrate (NO3-N), and dissolved organic carbon were tested. During the test, ozone effects on pH, dissolved oxygen (DO) and bromination were also monitored. Ozone concentrations were originally set to 0.05, 0.1, 0.15, 0.2 and 0.25 ppm, but actual treatment concentrations were maintained at 0.04, 0.11, 0.15, 0.19 and 0.23 ppm. The 5 ppm of NH4-N was oxidized within 12 hours in all concentrations of ozone treatments, with the average oxidizing rate of 0.65±0.28 mg NH4-N/L per hour. The 5 ppm of NO2-N was oxidized within 1.5 hours in all concentrations of ozone treatments at a rate of 4.5 mg NO2-N/L per hour. One out of 5 ppm NO3-N was oxidized by all concentration of ozone treatment after 24 hours. Ozone also oxidizes dissolved organic carbon and maintained the concentration at about 2.9±0.77 ppm from the 15 ppm of initial concentration by 12 hours. DO was increased from 5.9 ppm to 9.4 ppm within 30 minutes in all ozone treatment and stabilized thereafter. Bromate concentrations increased sharply within the first 6 hours of ozonation at the rate of 7.3±2.4 mg/L per hour in almost all ozone treatments; the rate decreased to 2.5±0.15 mg/L per hour thereafter. However, bromate concentration was not increased in the ammonia experiment until all ammonia was oxidized. Therefore, further studies are needed to determine the relationship between NH4-N concentration and bromate formation in seawater.

Keywords: ozone, organic carbon, bromate, ammonia, nitrite, nitrate

1. Introduction
Water quality is one of the most important factors in managing intensive aquaculture systems. Currently, researchers are attempting to find the simplest and cheapest way to maintain better water quality. Ozone has been widely used to sterilize pathogens from the supply and effluent water in aquaculture systems [1]. However, ozone treatment has been found to be effective on the removal of organic and inorganic metabolites in the aquaculture system [2].
Ozone can be applied in aquaculture because it is a powerful oxidative agent that has very unstable bonds in chemical chains. At low pH (<7), molecular ozone (O3) is the dominant form. When pH increases, O3 turns into very short-lived hydroxyl radicals and its oxidative potential increases. In aquaculture, ozone has been used for water disinfectant and water quality improvement [1]. Ozone also improves water quality by deactivating bacterial, fungal and viral pathogens in aquaculture system [2, 4, 5, 6]. Application of ozone in RAS (Recirculation Aquaculture System) has the purpose of using available water more efficiently. By applying ozone, it is able to increase water quality conditions because ozone removes dissolved organic compounds, ammonia and nitrite in addition to being a good disinfecting agent [7]. However, the use of ozone also brings some disadvantages to aquaculture systems such as the risk of bromate forming, ozone residual, and the high consumption of power to produce ozone [3].
Bromate ion (BrO3) is the highest oxidation state of the bromide ion. The bromate ion can be formed during the ozonation of bromide-containing waters [8]. Ozone oxidizes bromide to form hypobromite ion (OBr). Hypobromite continues to be oxidized to form bromate, or to form an unidentified species, possibly Bromine dioxide (BrO2), which regenerates bromide ion [9]. Brominated by-product formation in ozonated water is influenced by bromide ion concentration, the source and concentration of natural organic matter (NOM), pH, ozone dose, and reaction time [10]. It is important to note that ozonation under higher pH conditions produces higher bromate concentrations, such that with sufficient bromide and ozone applied to meet an ozone residual for disinfection; tens of micrograms per liter of bromate can be formed [11].
Ozone is able to oxidize ammonia to some other relevant molecule. Ammonia may decompose to N2 by several chain reactions, but ozone does not decompose ammonia into the innocuous N2. It is only transferring ammonia from water to the atmosphere as the following reaction [12].
Br + O3 + H à HBrO + O2 ............................................ (1)
NH3 + HBrO à NH2Br + H2O....................................... (2)
NH2Br + HBrO à NHBr2 + H2O................................... (3)
NH2Br + NHBr2 àN2 + 3Br + 3H ................................ (4)
Ammonia will oxidize to nitrite and continues to oxidize into nitrate by ozone via;
NH4+ + 3O3 à NO2 + 3O2 + 2H + H2O........................ (5)
NO2 + O3 à NO3 + O2................................................... (6)
Ammonia could also oxidize directly into nitrate by the following reaction [13];
NH4+ + 4O3→ NO3+ 2H+ + H2O + 4O2......................... (7)
As mentioned above, ammonia will oxidized into nitrite and the final product will be nitrate.
Other than ammonia, ozonation also decreases organic carbon concentrations by: direct oxidation of organic compounds; coagulation of small organic particle into larger ones and more easily removed by mechanical filtration; and breaking down large, “refractory,” organic molecules into more biodegradable ones [14]. Ozonation of NOM may create organic polymers that either enhances coagulation of are more easily coagulated; Ozone can breakdown complexes Fe and Mn which might be tied up with NOM; the release of the oxidized metals creates a source of coagulant [32]. Ozone could oxidize nitrite, nitrate, and ammonia along with TOC in the water. In another side, ozonation can also produce the brominated by-products. However, to our best knowledge there is no report considering on the effect of several levels of ozone concentrations on water quality parameters such as ammonia, nitrite, nitrate and TOC. Therefore, a series of experiments to determine the oxidation effects of ozone concentrations on ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, and TOC were conducted. During the ozone treatments, changes of dissolved oxygen, pH, and bromate were monitored.

2. Materials and methods
2.1. System Design
All the treatments were done within a fume hood (Figure 1). Ten liters of acrylic cylinders were filled with 7 Liters each of sea water. Four tubes were installed in each with an ozone spreader (air stone) and bar thermometer. Ozone was introduced into each cylinder through a plastic hose and air stone. An airflow meter was installed for each cylinder to measure and adjust the amount of ozone added to the water. An ozone generator (Ozonetech, PC57L-10) with the capacity of 13 L/min of ozone gas was used. The fume hood was equipped with a ventilation system to remove excess ozone from the cylinders. An air temperature controller was installed in the fume hood to adjust the experimental temperature to 25oC (Fig. 1).


2.2. Experimental Procedure
After the system was setup, each acrylic cylinder was filled with 7 L of filtered seawater. The temperature was set at 25oC and the initial DO, pH, and ozone concentrations were measured before ozone was injected. When the system was stabilized (about 20 minutes) and initial water quality parameters had been measured, ozone was continuously injected into the water at the rate of 1 L/min, 2 L/min, 3 L/min, 4 L/min and 5 L/min. When ozone reached equilibrium concentration, initial source of each measurement was added to the water and samples were taken periodically. Water samples were periodically collected for analysis of ozone and other water quality parameters. Periodical sampling intervals were established, dependent on the speed of changes of water quality parameters monitored.
Experiments were held in four different treatments, all the treatments were used the identical system as explained above. The only differentiation in each treatment is the chemical used for water parameter (ammonia, nitrite, nitrate and TOC). Anhydrous ammonium chloride (NH4Cl) was used as the ammonia source with a concentration of 5 ppm. While the Sodium nitrite (NaNO2), with the initial concentration of 5 ppm, was used as the nitrite source. In case of nitrate, Sodium nitrate (NaNO3) with the initial concentration of 5 ppm was used as the nitrate source. And then Glucose (dextrose) was used as the carbon source in the equal concentration of TOC reached 15 ppm [15].
Ozonation of seawater resulted in side effects in addition to the main parameter measured. Therefore, while the maintaining ozone equilibrium concentration, bromate, DO and pH changes were also measured.

2.3. Water Quality Measurement Procedure
2.3.1. Ozone Measurement
Measurement of ozone residual (ozone equilibrium concentration) in the water was done using Spectrophotometer Hach DR-2800. Samples were taken as much as the volume of the ampoules. Reagent (indigo reagent) was prepared and sealed inside of the commercial ampoule. The ampoules were immersed into the water treatments and water samples were collected. After ampoules were full filled with the water sample, ampoules were raised, reversed and shakes gently. A few second after, samples were measured under the spectrophotometer in wave length of 600 nm. Because of ozone is very unstable material, so constantan loss of absorbance of indigo reagent were used to calibrated and determined the ozone concentration in the water [33, 34].

2.3.2. Ammonia Measurement
Anhydrous ammonium chloride (NH4Cl) was used as ammoniac source (APHA, AWWA, WEF. 1995). To observe the ammoniac degradation “Manual Phenate Method” was used by combined it with spectrophotometer OPRON 3000. The measurement was done based on the standard method book for examination of water and wastewater by APHA, AWWA, and WEF 1995. In this method, six reagents were made, standardized, and used to determined ammoniac concentration.

2.3.3. Nitrate and Nitrite Measurement
The nitrate source was used is sodium nitrate (NaNO3) while the nitrite source was used is sodium nitrite (NaNO2) (APHA, AWWA, WEF. 1995). Samples were filtered first with the whatman paper to remove suspended solid contain. After filtered, samples were enriched with color development reagent. The samples were then measured its absorbance level using spectrophotometer. For nitrate the spectrophotometer at 543 nm of wave length was used, while measurement of nitrate was done under the wave length of 220 nm and 275 nm.

2.3.5. TOC Measurement
Glucose (dextrose) was used as the carbon source and TOC concentration were conditioned to reach the level of 15 ppm. TOC measurement was done under the HiPerTOC analyzer. For total organic carbon measurement, sample was injected into a gas-sparged reactor containing acidified potassium persulfate (K2S2O8) solution; continued by exposures the solution using elevated ultraviolet (UV) radiation to enhance the oxidation. The concentration of total organic carbon (TOC) was measured as the difference between "total carbons (TC)" and "inorganic carbon (IC)" results (Thermo Electron Corporation, 2009).
2.3.6. Bromate Measurement
Bromate concentrations in this experiment were measured using spectrophotometer under the wave length of 590 nm. The reagents used were acetate buffer, phenol red indicator solution, chloramines-T solution, sodium thiosulfate, and bromide stock solution. Determination of bromate concentration could be done by comparing the data to the calibration curve of bromate. (APHA, AWWA, WEF. 1995).

3. Results and Discussion
3.1. Ozone Equilibrium Concentration
Each loading rate of ozone treatment was resulting in different level of ozone equilibrium concentration in the seawater. One L/min treatment resulting 0.04 ppm, while 2, 3, 4 and 5 L/min of ozone loading treatment resulting the equilibrium concentration of 0.11, 0.15, 0.19 and 0.23 ppm of ozone respectively. The loading rate of ozone and its equilibrium level in the water were never have in the same level, as a part is diluted in the water and the other part is evaporate to the air as its buffer.

3.1. Ammonia Oxidation
Five ppm of ammonia in seawater has entirely oxidized no longer than 12 h by ozone (Fig.2). In this experiment, ammonia removal by ozone was relatively very fast in the first 3 hours, and it’s continue slowly within next 9 hours until all ammonia concentration was oxidized. Ammonia removals by ozone were classified into two groups, which are the lower and higher ones. The lower ozone treatment (1, 2, and 3 L/min of ozone) has the removal rate of 0.55±0.21 ppm/hour with the removal acceleration of y=1.2873Ln(x) +1.141 in average. The other is higher ozone treatment (4 and 5 L/min of ozone) with the removal rate of 0.75±0.20 ppm/hour by the removal acceleration of y=1.2108Ln(x) +1.3005 in average. As distinct from ozone treatment, ammonia concentrations in the water treated by common aeration were only remained in the initial concentration by air loading rate of 1, 2 and 3 L/min, while for air loading rate of 4 and 5 L/min it could reduce ammonia in about 5% from initial concentration.


By the reaction number 5 and 6 above, we know that ammonia could oxidized into nitrate accumulation either by direct or indirect reaction with ozone. In an identical culture system, different levels of ozone concentration were reported to have no effect on the oxidizing ability of ammonia [12]. The differentiation of ammonia removal rate in this experiment was suggested caused by foam fractionation. Because more air introduced into higher ozone treatment groups, more foam to accumulate on the surface of water treated. Tanaka and Matsumura have reported that the foam fractionation is able to remove ammonia from the water [16].

Although ammonia was removed from the water, nitrate accumulations were found increased rapidly in the first 12 hours and then the increment was slowing into final experiment (Fig.3). Ammonia was oxidized by ozone into nitrite and continuous to oxidize into nitrate. Here by this experiment, the ammonia loading rate of 5 ppm/day was oxidized to be nitrate as much as 15.4 ± 0.29 mg/L in 24 hours.


By the formulas of reaction no.5 and 6 also based on mass balance each molecule; the 5 mg/L of initial ammonia ideally should be oxidized into 17.23 mg/L of nitrate. The concentration of nitrate in this experiment was recorded at a level of 15.4 ± 0.29 mg/L. The difference between nitrate accumulated in this experiment and that in the calculation method is caused by the natural reaction involves ammonia ion. During the ozonation of ammonia, there are many possibilities for the formation of the other ions, such as brominated product, nitrogen ions, and other by-products [13]. In this experiment ammonia was transformed into nitrate and some other by-products by ozone oxidation.
3.2. Nitrite Oxidation
Ozone also reacted with nitrite and oxidized it into nitrates and other excess gas from the water. Five ppm of nitrite in seawater was oxidized completely within 90 minutes in all ozone treatment concentrations with an average removal rate of 4.45 ± 0.21 mg/L per hour (y= 1.3022Ln(x)-0.993). After the first 30 minutes, nitrite concentration decreased 80% from 5 ppm to 1 ppm, and then continuously decreased to near zero within 90 minutes (Fig.4).


This experiment was used five ppm of initial concentration because an initial nitrite concentration of less than 10mg/L is near the maximum nitrite concentration that would be found in an untreated, high density fish hatchery [17,18,19,20,21]. The rate of nitrite removal was very high in the first 30 minutes; this was similar to the result reported by Lin and Wu [31], who reported that nitrite removal using an electrochemical could remove the initial total nitrite level of 5 mg/L in more than 30 min. In the application of ozone in seawater, any ammonia will oxidized into nitrite, which is only a temporary phase because nitrite itself will then be oxidized by ozone into nitrate. Nitrite is the temporary phase of reaction, resulting the relatively short oxidation time of the nitrite concentration. The quick oxidation reaction of nitrite was also caused by the double reaction that could happen by involving a nitrite ion, that are the direct reaction of nitrite with ozone [13], and reaction between nitrite and bromide acid which resulted from the reaction of bromide and ozone [12. This result indicates that nitrifying bacteria, which decomposes ammonia and nitrite from the water, will no longer to be the limitation factor for aquaculture especially in RAS. In the conventional aquaculture especially in RAS, ammonia removal was done by nitrification bacteria, it is therefore even though water supply and food has increased, the maximum density of carrying capacity still limited by concentration of ammonia accumulated in the water since nitrobacteria population is limited to its space of growth. By applying ozonation method, ammonia removal will no longer depend on nitrobacteria population, it is reduced by ozone.

3.3. Nitrate Oxidation
Nitrate was oxidized from the initial concentration of 5 ppm to 3.95 ppm after 12 hours, and remained at that level thereafter (Fig.5). There were no significances different among the ozone treatments on nitrate oxidation. Nitrate removal rate averaged 0.36 ppm/h (y = -0.0851Ln(x) + 4.1748). Oxidation of nitrate by ozone was complete within 12 hours of treatment; after 12 hours there was no significant change (p>0.05) in nitrate concentration. The same cases with ozone treatment, the nitrate concentrations were also remaining in the initial concentration while the water was treated with the common aeration.


Nitrate is the final product of the nitrification process [22]. Therefore, it is accumulated in an intensive aquaculture system, especially in RAS. Ozone could not oxidize nitrate optimally because ozone and nitrate have the same number of active oxygen molecules .  Nitrate already has three atoms of oxygen, so it cannot be oxidized by ozone, which also has the same electron valence from the oxygen molecule. Unlike in the biological process of denitrification in which nitrobacteria decompose the NO3- –N in the water into N2 ion, which could then be easily released into the air, ozonation allows the nitrate remaining in treated water to accumulated easily. Therefore, denitrification may need to be part of the ozonation process when nitrate accumulation becomes toxic. So, preventing NO3- –N formation becomes the key point while the process of removing ammonia from the water by ozonation [12].

3.4. TOC Oxidation
TOC concentration has consistently dropped during the ozonation process, leveling off when the concentration reached 2.98 ± 0.77 ppm in all treatments after 12 hours except for the lowest ozone treatment which is leveling off in the concentration of 4.06+0.46 ppm after 24 hours (Fig.6). This means that TOC reached an equilibrium concentration and remained there after. The TOC oxidation rate could be divided into three groups, the lowest, medium, and highest ozone treatments with the oxidation rate of 1.65 ppm/hours, 2.22 ppm/hour, and 2.25 ppm/hour respectively. This experiment indicated that the lowest ozone treatment (1 L/min) was removing significantly (p<0.05) less TOC from the water while the other concentration were not significant different (p>0.05) on the removal rate.


            This experiment used glucose (C6H12O6) as the organic carbon source. The TOC initial concentration was adjusted to 15 mg/L of organic carbon ion. The initial TOC was selected because it was reported as the average TOC concentration remained in intensive aquaculture systems [14, 22]. Ozonation also reduced TOC levels by approximately 17 % [23]. In this experiment the lowest ozone treatment (1 L/min) was significantly less in removing organic carbon contained in the water. This statement was also confirmed by Rosenthal (1980), who explained that ozone at certain doses was not sufficient to oxidize organic compounds completely, but did break up large organic molecules into smaller, more easily biodegradable ones

3.5. Ozonation by-products
Bromate Formation
In this experiment, monitoring of bromate concentration in the seawater was done in three different treatment, those were bromate formation while ozonation of seawater without interferer, bromate formation while oxidation of ammonia and the last is the bromate formation while oxidation of TOC. Ozonation of seawater without any interferer were resulting in very high bromate formation. Bromate formation increased with ozone exposure time (Fig.7). Bromate concentration was increased sharply into 79.28 ppm as long as 24 hours of ozonation.


In the oxidation of ammonia, bromate formation was suppressed as long as ammonia still available in the water. Bromate concentration was remained at 0.33 ppm for the first 6 hours, and increased to 8.3 ppm for the next 6 hours, then dramatically increased thereafter (Fig.8).


In the oxidation of TOC, bromate formation also suppressed by the organic carbon contained in the water. During the first 12 hours, all bromate concentration was found below of 10 ppm except for 5 L/min of ozone treatment (Fig. 9). After the 12 hours, in the same time were the TOC also exhausted, bromate formation were sharply increase.


It is well known that ozonation of bromide-containing waters can oxidize the bromide ion (Br) to bromate (BrO3) ion within normal water quality ranges and treatment parameters [23, 8, 24, 9, 25, and 11]. The bromate ion (BrO3) is the highest oxidation state of the bromide ion and ozone oxidizes bromide to hypobromite ion (OBr) [8]. Hypobromite continues to be oxidized to bromate or to an unidentified species, possibly Bromine dioxide (BrO2), which regenerates bromide ion [9]. Formation of brominated by-product in ozonated waters is influenced by bromide ion concentration, the source and concentration of natural organic matter (NOM), pH, dose of ozone, and reaction time [11].
The conversion of bromide ion into bromine and bromate are shown in the following two formulas:
O3 + Br à O2 + OBr- ..................................................... (8)
2O3 + OBr- à 2O2 + BrO3- ............................................ (9)
Bromide reacts with ozone to produce oxygen and hypobromite; hypobromite is then oxidized by ozone into bromate and oxygen. According to Bowen [26], common seawater has average bromide ion (Br-) concentrations as high as 66 mg/L. Based on the above reactions, 66 mg/L of bromide ion could be converted into 105 mg/L bromate ion. In this experiment, the bromate reaches the level of 79.28 mg/L. This bromate concentration was relatively high compared to theoretical bromate production. The simplest method to decompose the oxidizing bromines is to use a reducing agent like an activated carbon column or by using Na2SO3 [12].
In this experiment bromate concentration did not increase for 12 hours, during the time that ammonia exists. Moreover, bromate will not be formed as long as ammonia is present in the water system. Bromide will be oxidized by ozone and react with ammonia into dibromamine (NHBr2) or hypobromous acid (HOBr) and the other bromine ion [16]. In addition, ammonia has been suggested to be a potential quenching agent that may act to minimize bromate formation in water [27]. Ozone which was diluted to the water will react with existing TOC first before it can be reacting with bromide ion to form bromate. In addition, result of oxidation of TOC by ozone could produce compounds that can react with brominated ion such as BrO3-, Br-, Cl-, and SO42- before it is oxidized by ozone into bromate. Hofmann suggested that the formation of bromate may be highly coupled with the characterization and concentration of NOM [27].

Dissolved Oxygen Changes
DO levels increased in all ozone treatments (Fig. 10). When ozone was introduced into the water, DO was increase from the level of 6.23 ppm in average into 9.2 – 9.6 ppm and stabilize thereafter. Even though ozone increasing DO into super saturation level, common aeration treatment only promote DO to reach saturation level at 7.2 ppm in average. No differences in DO levels were found among the aeration groups after 30 minutes and thereafter (p>0.05).


In this experiment DO was increased with ozonation. Ozone is a triatomic oxygen molecule (O3), very reactive and ready to decay to oxygen (O2) and enhance oxygen concentration in the water. Dissolved oxygen (DO) is a critical parameter for aquatic organisms [28]. In fish culture, rather than temperature or other water quality parameters, DO is the most important. In highly intensive aquaculture systems like RAS, the ability to add dissolved oxygen to the water is the first priority to increase carrying capacity. Therefore, ozonation in high density culture systems might be useful for increasing DO and carrying capacity.

pH Changes
The pH levels increased significantly in all groups of ozone treatment. Additionally, pH levels increased with time from the initial pH of 8.1 in average to 8.5 ~ 8.7 (Fig. 11) by 20 minutes and stabilized thereafter.  


Ozone decays in the water partly to reactive of OH-radicals. Therefore, the assessment of an ozone process always involves the reactions of two species: ozone and OH-radicals. When these OH-radicals are the dominant particles in the solution, it is called an advanced oxidation process (AOP). The decay of ozone to OH-radicals in natural waters is characterized by a fast initial decrease of ozone, followed by a second phase in which ozone decreases by first order kinetics. When the formation of OH-radicals is increased, the pH value will also increase [29, 30]. These hydroxide ions act as an initiator for the decay of ozone [29]:
O3 + OH- → HO2- + O2 .................................................. (10)
O3 + HO2- → OH + O2 •- + O2 ....................................... (11)
O3 + O2 •- → O3•- + O2 .................................................... (12)
O3•- + H2O → OH + OH- + O2 ...................................... (13)
The radicals that are produced during the reactions above can induce other reactions with ozone, causing more OH-radicals to be formed. In addition, pH influences the acid/base equilibriums of some compounds and also the reaction speed of ozone.

In the application of ozone to enhance water quality in aquaculture, ozone could remove ammonia and nitrite completely from the water. Although nitrate concentration potentially accumulated, nitrate is not really toxic for organism until the special condition. Ozonation of seawater have the compensation to form bromate ion, but with the existence of ammonia and organic carbon in the water, bromate forming could be suppressed depend on the ammonia and TOC concentration.
However, in the real application of ozonation in aquaculture, water was contained with complexes chemicals and biological compound. It’s supposed to have the effect from combination of every factor to synergistically interfere the bromate formation. Nevertheless in separated experiment, there was no one of factor could promote the bromate formation, those all were functioned as inhibition agent of bromate formation. Based on this experiment result also compared to the chemical reaction in some references, ozonation can be applied safely into RAS. By means so, bromate formation level in the RAS with synergetic effect of existence of all component need to be studied and it should be the major consideration while application of ozone.

The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial support from Jae-Yoon Jo, Professor of Aquaculture Engineering Laboratory, Pukyong National University. Thank to Dr. In-Bae Kim and Dr. Seong-Yoon Hong and all the member of Aquaculture Engineering Laboratory, Pukyong National University.

[1]. Ghomi, M. R., Esmaili, A., Vossoughi, G., Keyvan, A., Nazari, R. M., 2007. Comparison of ozone, hydrogen peroxide and removal of infected eggs for prevention of fungal infection in sturgeon hatchery. Fisheries Science; 73: 1332–1337, Japanese Society of Fisheries Science.
[2].    Rosenthal, H., 1980. Ozonation and sterilization. Symposium on New Development in Utilization of Heated Effluents and of Recalculation Systems for Intensive Aquaculture. FAO EIFAC/ 80/Symp: R/8/May. European Inland Advance Committee, Norway. 1980 – p. 5
[3].    Rice, Rip G., & Netzer, Aharon., 1985. Handbook of Ozone Technology and Applications. Volume 1. Ann Arbor Science. Boston : Butterworth. 389 pp
[4].    Owsley, D., 1991. Ozone for disinfecting hatchery-rearing water. In: Colt, J., White, R. (Eds.), American Fisheries Society Symposium, vol. 10. American Fisheries Society, Bethesda, MD, pp. 417–420.
[5].    Liltved, H., Hekteon, H., Efraimsen, H., 1995. Inactivation of bacterial and viral fish pathogens by ozonation or UV irradiation in water of different salinity. Aquaculture Engineering. 15, 107–122
[6].    Wedemeyer, G.A., 1996. Physiology of fish in intensive culture. International Thompson Publishers, New York, NY. 232 p.
[7].    Magara, Y., M. Itoh, et al. 1995. Application of ozone to water treatment and power consumption of ozone generating systems. Progress in Nuclear Energy 29 (Supplement 1): 175-182.
[8].    Symons, J.M., 1999. The Drinking Water Dictionary, American Water Works Association, Denver, CO. p. 47.
[9].    Glaze and Weinberg, 1999 W.H. Glaze and H.S. Weinberg, Identification and occurrence of ozonation by-products in drinking water, AWWARF , Denver.
[10].  Bonacquisti, T. P.,  2006. A drinking water utility's perspective on bromide, bromate, and ozonation. Toxicology 221(2-3), 145-148.
[11].  Faust, S. D., and Aly, O. M., 1998. Chemistry of Water Treatment. (Second edition), Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, FL (1998) p. 69.
[12].  Yang, M., Uesugi, K., Myoga, H., 1999. Ammonia removal in bubble column by ozonation in the presence of bromide. Elsevier Science Ltd. Water Researc Vol. 33, No. 8, pp. 1911-1917
[13].  Haag W.R., Hoigne J. and Bader H. (1984) Improved ammonia oxidation by ozone in the presence of bromide ion. Water Research. 18(9), 1125-1128.
[14].  Krumins, V., Ebeling, J., and Wheaton, F., 2000. Ozone dose and equilibrium TOC in recirculating systems. Pp. 1-4. In: Proceeding of the third International Conference on Recirculating Aquaculture. Virginia Polytechnic and State University, Sea Grant Program. Blacksburg, Virginia.
[15].  APHA., AWWA., WEF., 1995. Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater. 19th edition. APHA. Washington, DC. 1325 p.
[16].  Tanaka, J and Matsumura, M., 2002. Kinetic studies of removal of ammoniac from seawater by ozonation. Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology. Society of Chemical Industry. 77:649-656
[17].  Liao P. B., and Mayo R. D., 1972. Intensified fish culture combining water reconditioning with pollution abatement. Aquaculture Engineering. 3, 61.
[18].  Otte G., and Rosenthal H., 1979. Management of a closed brackish water system for high density fish culture by biological and chemical water treatment. Aquaculture Engineering. pp. 18 – 169.
[19].  Poxton M. G., and Allhouse S. B., 1982. Water quality criteria for marine fisheries. Aquaculture Engineering. pp. l – 153.
[20].  Kruner G., and Rosenthal H., 1983. Efficiency of nitrification in trickling filters using different substrate. Aquaculture Engineering. 2, 49 .
[21].  Bovendeur J., Eding E. H., Henken A. M., 1987. Design and performance of a water recirculation system for high-density culture of the African catfish. Aquaculture Engineering, 63, 329 p.
[22].  Tango, M. S., Gagnon, G. A., 2003. Impact of ozonation on water quality in marine recirculation system. Elsevier. Aquaculture engineering 29 (2003) 125 – 137
[23].  Gillogly, T., Najm, I., et al., 2001. Bromate formation and control during ozonation of low bromide waters. In: AWWARF, Denver, CO. 156 p.
[24].  Singer, P. C., 1999. Formation and Control of Disinfection By-Products in Drinking Water. American Water Works Association, Denver, CO, p. 195.
[25].  Jacangelo, J.G., 1997. Technical Memorandum: Bromide Disinfection By-Product Study. Lorton/Occoquan System Evaluation. Fairfax County Water Authority, Merrifield, VA.
[26].  Bowen, H. J. M., 1966. Trace element in biochemistry. Academic Press, New York, 241 p.
[27].  Hofmann, R. 2000. Using ammonia to inhibit bromate formation during ozonation. Ph.D. Thesis. University of Toronto, Toronto, ON. 218 p.
[28]. Wheaten, F. W., 1977. Aquaculture Engineering. John Wiley & Sons. New York. 708 p.
[29]. Ershov, B. G., and Morozov, P. A., 2008. Decomposition of Ozone in Water at pH 4 – 8. Russian Journal of Applied Chemistry. Vol. 81 No. 11 2008, pp. 1777-1780
[30]. Lenntech Co. Ltd., 1998. Lenntech Water treatment & purification holding B.V. Technical University of Delft, Netherlands. (http://www.lenntech.com)
[31].  Lin, S.H. and Wu, C.L. 1996. Removal of nitrogenous compounds from aqueous solution by ozonation and ion exchange. Water Research 30, 1851 – 1857.
[33].  Bader, H., and Hoigné, J., 1981. Determination of ozone in water by the indigo method. Water Research 15(4), 449-456.
[34]. Hach Company. 2009. Hach 2800 user manual. 3rd Edition, November 2009. German. 814 p.

List Of Figure
Fig.1. Schematic drawing of experimental system for testing oxidation effects of ozone on ammonia, nitrite, nitrate and organic carbon.
1.     Ozone generator                4. Air flow meter              7. Aeration stone
2.     Connector hose                  5. Air conditioner             8. Work bench
3.     Pressure gauge                   6. Acrylic cylinder           9. Thermo switch

Fig.2. Effect of 5 different concentration of ozonation on ammonia removal rates. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different.

Fig.3. Changes of nitrate concentrations during ammonia ozonation. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different.

Fig.4. Relationship between nitrite removal and nitrite concentration in seawater with 5 different ozone treatments. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different.

Fig.5. Nitrate oxidation rate treated by five ozone concentrations. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different
Fig.6. Change of TOC concentration in the water treated with five different levels of ozone. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different

Fig.7. Bromates formation for 24 hours of ozonation process. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different.

Fig.8. Relationship between ammonia concentrations and bromate formation during the oxidation treatment of ammonia. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different

Fig.9. Increment of bromate formation during oxidation of TOC treatment. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different.

Fig.10. Increment of DO concentration during 5 different levels of ozonation. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different.

Fig.11. Changes of pH level during ozonation process. Superscripts of the same letter at the end of each treatment concentration were not significantly different